Q: What would you do if you disagree with your supervising physician in the treatment plan for a patient?
What are they looking for?
How you react to stressful and confrontational situations
No one wants to work with someone or allow someone to represent their institution that’s going to be a jerk if you disagree with them
That you can kindly and appropriately advocate for your patients
What to avoid
Saying that you would do what you thought was right no matter what your SP says
In the same light, stating that you would do whatever your supervising physician said because they are in charge is also not the right answer
If you go to another colleague– never ever bad mouth the physician involved in the course of treatment.
What to say
You would talk to you SP in a way that you were asking for education regarding the course of treatment. In other words something along the lines of “This isn’t a course of treatment I am familiar with would you mind giving me some information so I can better understand?”
If after you’ve asked for clarification you still don’t agree to the extent that you think the patient may suffer–talk to your colleagues or another SP about what they think the best course of treatment would be.
Always remember and make it a point that you would not seek another opinion until after talking to your initial SP.
Always promote collaboration and learning into your answer whenever someone asks you about a controversial situation.